Accelerating Patient Payments in a Time of Crisis

With millions of Americans now out of work with limited to no income, prioritizing bills becomes even more challenging.  According to the Federal Reserve, approximately 40% of all Americans don’t have enough savings to cover a $400 dollar emergency. Compared to rent/mortgage, utility or credit card bills, medical bills have traditionally been designated as a low priority.  Unfortunately, under current conditions, we’re likely to see these numbers rise even higher.  So what can be done in order to strike the balance between assisting consumers-in-need while increasing the priority to pay medical bills?

A singular approach won’t work. Instead, Revenue Cycle Management (RCM) groups should implement multiple tactics simultaneously including contactless engagement and flexible payment plans. Especially with laptop and cell phone use at an all-time high for work-related actions, electronic engagement not only eliminates the need to handle paper, but almost assures that messaging for new bills and payment reminders will be seen. Certainly, this increases the likelihood of action taken on those bills. Recent data from our system shows rates as high as 90% for guarantors/patients who clicked a text-based bill (or reminder) link, following through to the payment system. Often, the action taken in that system will be to set up a payment plan.

Payment plans are proving to be valuable for both providers and patients during these times...as long as you are doing them the right way.  If you rely on a patient to open a paper statement, understand their balance, pick up a phone and call an office (or remote call center resource) to talk about payment plan arrangements, then you are set up for disappointing results. As an effective alternative, make the delivery of the bill contactless, make login simple, then prompt the patient to accept established payment plan guidelines via a secure cloud solution. 

We’ve been tracking the numbers on payment plans managed through our system and the results are pretty telling.  Since March 15th, a date many consider the realization of drastic changes to normalcy due to the pandemic, there has been a 122% increase in patients utilizing this option.  One RCM organization in particular during this timeframe has had more than 7 times the normal daily number of payment plans established, a feat they only achieved once from February 1st thru mid-March. These plan parameters are established by the financial or RCM team. This allows the patient to simply accept terms or alter them, as long as those alterations meet the criteria. Typically, this includes a minimum acceptable dollar amount or maximum number of installments. It’s the proper balance of simplicity and empathy without losing control. 

In fact, these plans are so beneficial for both patient and provider, we’ve seen higher overall collection rates in April than we’d seen for the same period of February, before the pandemic officially “started”. These plans are obviously allowing patients to amortize costs of healthcare over several months while cash-flow is down. Some patients are so appreciative, they’re proactively thanking provider organizations for the flexibility and simplicity. One patient wrote, “I literally would have ignored this if you sent me a bill in the mail. I got your text, clicked the link, entered my date-of-birth and accepted your terms. Umm...thank you!” For the patient, it’s the break they’d expect from any consumer relationship right now. For the provider, payment plans are money in the bank should the Covid-19 pandemic continue for an extended period of time.

PatientPay Oversubscribes $6M Funding Round

Funding to be used for significant expansion with Revenue Cycle Management (RCM) operations for healthcare providers

PatientPay the leading patient payments partner for acute, ambulatory, and specialty care, today announced it secured $6.15 million in growth financing. The investment will be used to significantly expand its ability to serve the needs of Revenue Cycle Management (RCM) companies as well as further enhance its omni-channel patient payments platform.

The round was led by Mosaik Partners and the Teaghlach Family Office, existing investors, with participation from other current and new investors. This financing supports PatientPay’s industry-leading end-to-end patient engagement and payment solution that captures more payments while making the patient billing experience an integrated part of patient care.

“This new financing will enable PatientPay to bring more innovation and efficiencies in healthcare with electronic strategies for patient payments that serve to drive more payments, lower the cost of care while providing a positive patient experience during the billing process,” said Tom Furr, PatientPay’s CEO. 

“PatientPay has been partnering successfully with several of the largest healthcare RCM operations in the country who use our omni-channel strategies to target mobile patient payments via text and email as the initial touch points for healthcare bills. Time and again, we’ve seen when patients understand their financial responsibilities – and feel more in control of their healthcare payment experience – it is a win-win-win equation for them, the RCM and the healthcare provider,” Furr said.

According to a recent report from KeyBank, “The U.S. healthcare industry has been notoriously slow to embrace new  payment systems and processes, largely due to the complexity that arises from regulatory and privacy requirements. Only 17% of consumers receive a medical bill electronically, despite over 70% preferring electronic statements.” In stark contrast, PatientPay’s electronic medical billing has yielded the following success metrics:

  • 53% of patient statements are paid in the first 28 days.

  • 60% of electronic bills are paid online.

  • 63% of payments are made via customized payment plans.

PatientPay’s patents and software leverage existing central billing office infrastructure and systems to bill and reconcile patient payments using existing insurance claims data that ultimately simplifies the entire billing process for the patient. This unique architecture enables PatientPay to match patient bills to their insurance’s explanation of benefits (EOB) allowing patients to trust their bill.  PatientPay’s flexible payment plan options help patients better manage certain bills that might be difficult to pay in full due to the continual rise of patient financial responsibility. PatientPay RCM clients use integrated analytics to provide smarter collection strategies to better understand how patients navigate and pay their bills.

PatientPay’s platform gives RCM operations visibility into their complete patient payment strategy by utilizing their current eligibility and estimation solution as well as integrating it into their early out call centers. PatientPay has as much as doubled patient payment collections compared to RCM’s prior collection capabilities.

To learn more about how PatientPay drives end-to-end patient payments and, ultimately, value for both patients and providers, visit www.patientpay.com.

The Time is NOW to Implement a Mobile Billing Strategy

Collecting open balances effectively from patients in the healthcare space has proven to be extremely difficult.  This is made evident by an average collection rate of only 18% before giving a patient balance to a collections agency or writing it off.  So why don’t patients feel the need to pay their healthcare bills?

Perhaps that’s the wrong question to be asking.  Our data shows that the majority of patients are wanting and willing to pay their healthcare bills as long as they can understand what they owe and why they owe it, coupled with options for receiving and paying them.  So instead of asking “what’s wrong with the patients?” instead try asking “what’s wrong with our strategy?”

80% of the time, you already have a key piece of info that can be used to improve:  a patient’s mobile phone number. 

There is a growing percentage of your patient population who will ONLY interact with your organization in a timely manner if they are able to handle everything from a mobile device.  In fact, a 2019 study* found that over 70% of patients prefer electronic statements even though only 17% of medical groups offer electronic solutions for billing and payments. From receiving a text to viewing their bill to making a payment, the process must be easy for the patient to understand and use and there MUST be options for how to handle the payment.  

It’s becoming impossible to ignore the numbers that a mobile-forward strategy can bring to your patient collection efforts.  After just 3 months of implementing a new process involving proactive and more frequent electronic communication, a high-volume healthcare billing organization has realized the following results:

  • 60% of electronic bills that were sent were paid online

  • 63% of these payments were set up on a payment plan with an average installment of 9 months

  • 58% of payments were the result of purely electronic communication (no paper statement sent), resulting in a 60% total reduction in paper statement volume/costs.

What does this tell us?  That an omni-channel patient billing strategy with an emphasis on text and mobile capabilities, along with traditional paper and IVR offerings, really works.  

So, providers and their third-party RCM partners should look beyond the concept that patients are slow to act. Instead, take a look at your billing strategy to determine if you are utilizing the necessary tools for offering the most effective patient financial experience. 

   

*Jill Frew, Cain Brothers Industry Insights, April 2019

PatientPay Announces New Patent for ‘Instant Integration for Installment Payments’ for its Patient Payment Solution

Patented Technology Permits Integration for Payment Plans for Pre or Post Service

PatientPay, the leading end-to-end patient payment solution focused on the complex financial challenges facing specialty healthcare, announces the issuance of a patent to reduce the level of effort a medical group must perform to set up an integrated payment plan for both time-of-service and post visit patient statements.

 At the core of “Instant Integration for Installment Payments” is US Patent No. 10,410,187, a business process that enables a quick, easy and reliable connection with any currently available medical group billing system.  The process was developed and patented by PatientPay and is recognized as a significant advancement in the automation of healthcare practices in the United States.  This patent is in addition to PatientPay’s three other patents 8,155,983, 8,204,764 and 8,214,233.

 The Medical Group Management Association reports that the typical medical group sends, on average, 3.3 paper statements before payment is secured. PatientPay reduces the number of paper statements required to capture patient payments by providing electronic bills via text and email online. According to Cain Brothers, “Only 17 percent of consumers receive a medical bill electronically, despite over 70% preferring electronic statements.” This number is expected to grow with the ongoing increase in USPS postage rates.

 “PatientPay’s patented integration capability is the latest example of our commitment to bring the healthcare transaction cost down by leveraging automation through the existing healthcare payment infrastructure,” said Tom Furr, PatientPay’s CEO.  “With this technology we are eliminating the cost of manual back-end processing that’s required by other patient payment vendors.” 

 PatientPay is pleased to offer medical group billing vendors and revenue cycle management companies’ virtually instant access to our cost-effective service for their clients.  PatientPay permits seamless patient payment data posting and offers a better payment experience for patients.

What Would Steve Jobs Say?

More than likely you’ve purchased a song or many songs from iTunes as my family and I have.  Has it occurred to you that when you buy for your iPhone, iPad or Mac it’s one seamless process?

Think about it for a moment.  Do you search for it in one application then toggle over to a different application to pay for the tune and then toggle over to another application to listen it?  The answer is no.  The brilliance of iTunes is that you can do it all within one application; a single application that performs multiple tasks. 

It occurred to me while at a conference on “healthcare innovation” this simple approach to usability is still not the accepted method in healthcare.  The speakers spoke with authority on how users would have to exit out of, or toggle from, their billing system then log into a payment portal after having downloaded data.  I thought - what would Steve Jobs say about the user experience in healthcare even though we are now in the year 2019 not 1999 if he was alive today?  I imagine it would a scathing commentary after Apple did a deal with Epic.  My next step was to pose the same question to my fellow conference attendees.  Uniformly, the reply was: “this is just how healthcare works.”  Really?  Since when is complacency a prudent business strategy?

A symptom of complacency is a lack of clarity when it comes to seeing and understanding marketplace wants and needs.  If the “healthcare innovators” conducted even a little reconnaissance they’d see that patients and medical group/RCM personnel do not like to toggle from application-to-application. 

Regardless of what sort of application you’re developing or selling, if you’re not attuned to the usage preferences of those dealing with your software every day, you are putting your long-term viability at risk.  A kludgey user-experience puts complacent vendors at risk, especially as others are willing to address design and usability the way Steve Jobs did religiously.  Usability is what differentiates and provides an edge when competing for users and market share.  I would suggest you look at how Blackberry is doing today versus Apple or Samsung to see just how much value people place on ease-of-use.

So, like Apple has done, how do you keep your current customers fiercely loyal to your product, attract new ones and drive your competitors crazy trying to keep up?  Keep their experience with your product in mind at all times and move quickly to embed all key functions of their workday processes into your application and eliminate that troubling tendency to toggle.  By doing so you create a unified user experience, put up significant barriers to switching and drive greater revenue, as your customers become your greatest salespeople…just like Apple. 

Let’s heed Steve Jobs’ words: “Innovation distinguishes between a leader and follower.”

What is a Payment Facilitator or PayFac?

We are finding many Revenue Cycle Management (RCM) companies who have been given terrible information about how to collect and process patient payments from their existing credit card vendor.  In the Payment Card Industry (PCI) that includes Visa, Mastercard, Discover and Amex there is a credit card processing classification call Payment Facilitator or PayFac.  PayFacs are allowed to collect payments directly from a patient and then forward those payments over to the their clients.  Companies such as Square are classified as a PayFac but are required to meet very stricture rules set up by the PCI industry as well as meet money transmitters rules that are regulated by state banking commissioners.  As you will see below just to be approved to become a PayFac by a credit card processor the process is arduous and expensive.  I would expect to spend around $50,000 on the PCI audit if you can even get compliant.  With regards to the money transmitter rules each of the 49 states require a money transmitter surety bond with widely ranging amounts from as little as $25,000 to over $1 million and maintaining a minimum capital requirementSquare was fined in Florida $507,000 for not being registered as a PayFac.  

If you are an RCM company who is currently collecting payments from patients with those funds being deposited into your bank account and then forwarding these funds over to your medical groups or hospitals you are a Payment Facilitator or PayFac.  If this is the case you will be shut down immediately by Visa/Mastercard/Amex as well as risk state fines such as the one levied on Square once discovered.

Below are the requirements to become a PayFac from one of the largest credit card processor in the country:

Business Financial Background

1. PFac/PF Submission Form with PFac Questionnaire and Site Visitation Form

2. Summary of Business history and operations - Describe the business history, model, products/services and operational infra-structure to support PFac model.

3 (a) Articles of Incorporation or Partnership Documents

3 (b) DBA  - Fictitious Name Filing Required

4 Two (2) years Corporate Audited Financial Statements and Interim Financial Statements including P&L and Balance Sheet. If audited are not available, then statements prepared in accordance with GAAP.

5. Two (2) years Corporate Tax Returns

6. Principals' biographical profile and work history/resume for signer’s with 20% or more ownership

7. Two (2) years Personal Tax Returns OR Personal Financial Statements for Principals with 20% or more ownership

8. Names, addresses, telephone #, Social Security #, and % of Ownership for Principals with 20% or more ownership

9. Copy of Driver's License for Principals with 20% or more ownership

10. Current Merchant Processing Statements (previous 3 months)

11. Bank Reference(s) - Provide the Bank, Contact Person & telephone number, and ABA/DDA Numbers.

Business Operations

12. Organization chart of Risk Management staffing by function (Underwriting, Fraud, Risk, etc). Provide details the number of employees on the Risk Management staff, and background/experience profile or resumes on Senior Risk Managers.

13. Document the Process, Policies, and Procedures on the following:

13 (a) Know Your Customer (KYC) - Describe the methods/tools used to “validate” the Business Operations and the Principals (Owners) of Sub-Merchants.

13 (b) Fraud Monitoring - Describe the processes/reporting/systems to monitor Fraud among Sub-merchant transactions.

13 (c) On-going Risk Management - Describe the ongoing monitoring program to manage the Risk of Sub-merchants 

14. Sub-merchant Portfolio Information for all Sub-merchants which will participate in PFac program - see “Sub-merchant Info Spreadsheet”

15. Copy of Annual PCI Level 1 Compliance Version 3.1 PCI SSC Vallidation Document

16. How will the First Data Operating Guide be distributed to Sub Merchants?

16 (a) If on website please list website where it can be found by Sub Merchant?

17. Business Continuity Plan

18. AML Questionnaire (response to questions in file)

 PFac/PF Registration Sponsorship Documentation

19. Level 1 - AOC (Attestation of Compliance) Service Provider & Executive Summary from the ROC (Report on Compliance)

20. List of Third Party Service Providers who have access to Cardholder Data or offer any Third Party Services to your Sub-merchants  - e.g. Payment Gateways, etc.

21. List of Third Party Service Providers who will perform PIN Pad Encryption, if applicable (note there are additional requirements for ESOs - Encryption and Support Organization)

22. Name of Third Party Vendor conducting on-going Sub-merchant URL screening

23. Marketing materials, sales brochures, solicitation forms, websites (URL) used to solicit Sub-merchants

24. Website/Payment Page, if the PFac is accepting card payment on their website versus on the Sub-merchant's website

25. Sample of Sub-Merchant Application

26. Merchant Decline Letter - if Credit Score is a factor the letter must follow the Fair Credit Reporting Guidelines for decline of account

 Administrative

27. Registration Templates for MasterCard and Visa. 

28. Signed Contract with the PFac

29. Billing Instructions for initial Registration Fee and Annual Renewal Fee